1899: “A Famine of Honour”—The Khartoum Supply Scandal
From “Cat Among The Pigeons” (Privately circulated)
London has taken to scandal as a duck to burgundy sauce. This week’s delicacy: the Khartoum Supply Scandal, in which her Majesty’s soldiers were nourished, if that is the word, upon a consommé of corruption and congealed tallow. The War Office, having assured the world that every tin had been inspected, forgot to mention that the inspection was carried out by the supplier’s cousin, who can neither read nor smell.
The drama opens with Sergeant‑Major Alistair Crewe, a man of such plain speech that he cannot properly exist in England. Finding his regiment’s rations moving of their own accord, he made the mistake of reporting the matter. For this obstinate honesty, he was court‑martialled—as if truth itself had stolen a colonel’s brandy. Happily, the paperwork of justice moves so sluggishly that by the time his pardon arrived, the press had already crowned him the “Conscience of Omdurman.” The poor fellow must have felt quite ill at the promotion.
Enter Mrs. Dorothea Fanshaw, widow, moral crusader, and mistress of the thrillingly rhetorical pamphlet. Her Tinned Treachery: The Empire Betrayed by Its Own Larder sells briskly among those who never eat tinned anything. She has been received at clubs that once refused even her husband—proof, if any were needed, of how swiftly virtue rises through putrefaction. The colonels fawn, the bishops tremble, and the tea merchants quote her between mouthfuls of sponge cake. England adores virtue, especially when it can be gossiped about without being practised.
As for the villains, they are of that agreeable sort of Englishman whose cups sweat in the summer because their consciences no longer can. The contractor, one Mr. Henry Blatch of Freeman, Blatch & Co., maintains that the beef went bad “in transit.” Precisely where and how far, he does not say. His brother‑in‑law, conveniently employed at the War Office, has retired “for reasons of health”—a phrase which now means any ailment treatable by absence.
In Westminster itself, the air is thick with rebuke and disbelief, chiefly the latter. A Conservative junior declared in the commons: “We must remember that war is never tidy.” Indeed, nor are ledgers. Colonel Pennyfather of the Commissariat mumbled that “some deterioration is inevitable in tropical conditions.” Quite true; the trouble is that the beef deteriorated in Liverpool.
Meanwhile, the public clamours for an inquiry—the national cure for moral constipation. One is announced, to begin after the Season, presided over by a gentleman who has never eaten rations and seldom eaten anything else but pheasant. He will doubtless find all perfectly above board, except the beef.
In polite circles, much sympathy is expressed. Not, I hasten to add, for the dead soldiers, but for the distressed under‑secretary. “It is always so unfortunate,” sighs Lady Chervil, “when one’s family is involved in one’s work.” She made the remark with the serenity of a woman whose husband has no occupation at all. Her sister, Lady Blount, reports that she will henceforth serve no meat at her dinner parties—unless, of course, it comes from a duke.
Yet something grander than dining‑room panic is afoot. The British conscience, previously believed extinct, has been observed fluttering in Fleet Street, making small noises about national honour. These observations are premature. Honour does not thrive without oxygen, and there is never any to spare when the House is sitting. The only true corruption scandal that could shake Westminster would be one involving unpaid bills at the Club.
Still, there is amusement to be had in watching public virtue performed with such joyless skill. The Morning Trumpet insists we treat Sergeant‑Major Crewe as a hero. He will not enjoy it. England prefers its heroes silent, its widows pious, and its scandals infinite.
One cannot help but admire the symmetry: soldiers sent to secure Empire poisoned by its commerce; an under‑secretary’s wife feigning illness to avoid Mrs. Fanshaw’s crusade; the Government issuing circulars of “sincere regret,” the unique British formula for saying “mind your own business.” All is well, provided everyone dies in silence and the tins are unopened.
Meanwhile, the Marchioness of Malbury, from her distant moral high ground in Norwich, raises her lorgnette over the scene and pronounces: London smells decidedly imperial this week. The very odour of governance—rancid, self‑important, and perfectly preserved.
And so this report concludes with the solemn words recorded in The Army Victuallers’ Journal (February, 1899): “Supplies will henceforth be inspected with greater vigilance.” One assumes that means they will be glanced at by someone sober. Progress marches on, wagging its tail over graves.
You are here: States of Grace > Evidence