1393: Bell, book, and candle
From The Little Book of Fitzartur Foibles
They held the trial in the chapter house, with all the monks assembled as witnesses. Anetis stood in the centre, hands bound, face calm.
Brother Mallard read the charges: “That you did keep and maintain instruments of necromancy. That you did instruct others in forbidden arts. That you did, or did aid another to, perform the ritual of summoning upon the body of Brother Entenbraten, thereby causing his unnatural animation and subsequent destruction.”
“How do you answer?”
Anetis was quiet for a long moment. Then: “I kept the objects, yes. I instructed Father Anatroccolo in their history, yes. But I did not perform the ritual, nor do I know who did.”
“Yet you knew the ritual was possible,” Mallard pressed. “You knew it worked.”
“I knew that the old peoples believed it worked. I knew that the Church feared it enough to ban it repeatedly across eight centuries. I knew that something happens when bell, book, and candle are brought together over the newly dead. Whether what happens is what the pagans believed, or what the Church fears, or something else entirely—this I do not know.”
“You split hairs,” the Bishop said. “The effect is the same.”
“Is it?” Anetis turned to face him directly. “Your Grace, why does the Church herself use bell, book, and candle in the rite of excommunication? The priest rings the bell, closes the book, extinguishes the candle—symbolically cutting the person off from the community of the faithful, sending them into outer darkness. The same three objects, used inversely. If these objects have no power, why does the Church employ them? And if they do have power, where does it come from?”
A murmur ran through the assembled monks.
“The Church sanctifies and directs these objects to holy purpose,” Mallard said stiffly. “That is wholly different from—“
“Is it? Or has the Church simply claimed monopoly on a power that predates her? The pagans rang bells to summon the dead. The Church rings bells to summon the faithful to Mass—which commemorates a man who rose from the dead. The pagans kept books of names to anchor souls to memory. The Church keeps the Book of Life. The pagans lit candles to guide souls across thresholds. The Church lights the Paschal candle to celebrate Christ’s passage from death to life.”
Anetis’ voice grew stronger.
“Perhaps the Church bans this practice not because it is false, but because it is true. Because if ordinary people could ring a bell and call back their beloved dead, what need would they have for priests? What need for the intercession of saints, the saying of Masses, the purchasing of indulgences? The Church has built an entire economy on mediating between the living and the dead. The ritual of bell, book, and candle threatens that economy by suggesting the threshold can be crossed directly.”
“Heresy,” someone whispered.
“No,” Anetis said quietly. “Simply economics. The Church does not fear false magic—she dismisses that easily enough. She fears true magic that she cannot control. She fears the old ways not because they are demonic, but because they work, and because they do not require ordained hands.”
Bishop Aelfric stood. “You have condemned yourself. You admit the ritual is efficacious. You admit it bypasses the Church’s authority. You admit it works—and by that admission, you acknowledge trafficking with powers that, if they are not demonic, are certainly not divine.”
“Unless,” Anetis said, “they are simply natural. Properties of sound and symbol and light that the pagans discovered through observation, that the Church appropriated and hedged with restrictions, but which remain as available as rainfall or the turning of seasons. Perhaps there is no magic here at all—only knowledge that the Church would prefer remain forgotten.”
You are here: States of Grace > Fables