1860: Espèce deCanard
Lecture to a Ladies College in London
Ladies, permit me to address you not merely as a visitor but as one compelled by reason and reflection to share some thoughts on a most curious and persisting phenomenon of human affairs. It is an observation that cults—by which term I include religious orders and fervent bodies of belief—demonstrate an astonishing vigour to outlive empires, those grand political constructs upon which men so often stake their pride and ambition.
Consider for but a moment the fate of empires which have risen with great splendour—from Rome to Byzantium to the more recent glories of Spain and France—their armies vanquishing, their statesmen legislating, their flags advancing across continents; yet each, in time, has succumbed to decay, invasion, or internal rot. And yet amid the rubble of such imperial grandeur, those spiritual cults, born within or alongside these realms, do not merely persist but oftentimes burgeon with renewed fervour.
Take Christianity, for instance—a sect, once but a nascent cult within the vast Roman domain, now a force indefatigable, spreading far beyond the boundaries of that once imperious state which gave it birth under persecution and scorn. The empire fell, yet this cult thrived, clothed not in territorial dominion but in the allegiance and hearts of men and women.
It is my conviction, expressed as one more given to skepticism than credulity regarding such matters of faith, that neither cults nor empires ought by right to hold precedence in growth or influence. Both exist in a binary tension—power and belief locked in an endless dance—and both are fashioned by unimaginative and, dare I say, lazy men who devise repetitive and ultimately doomed patterns of dominance and submission.
Empires are constructed by force, coercion, and administration—mechanisms susceptible to entropy and rebellion. Cults, though subtler, rely on dogma unbending and social conformity, often stifling of innovation and individual freedom. Their endurance is less a mark of inherent virtue than of stubborn refusal to yield to the new or the just.
Thus, it is plausible to foresee that both institutions, destined as they are to cyclic failure, may one day yield place to forms of association more enlightened—formed not of conquest or credulous obedience, but of reason, equity, and humanity. Until then, we observe what history also teaches: that while cults may outlast empires, neither deserve unexamined perpetuation, and both owe their survival more to human weakness than to human excellence.
You are here: States of Grace > Philosophy